LowEffortSourdoughBread

Low Effort Sourdough Bread

I have tried many times to make sourdough bread using the conventional techniques. Nothing really worked well – unlike the true artist, making sourdough bread is not really a meditative act for me. I just want some reasonably good bread and the complicated kneading, proving & etc. of the usual process proved to be too frustrating for me to pursue it for any length of time. After repeated attempts, the following Low Effort Sourdough Bread process was developed. OK, true, it does resemble making a cake more than baking bread, but the results are a sourdough loaf of acceptable taste and reasonable (if unconventional) appearance. More importantly, since it only takes about 10 minutes of effort on my part, it gets done.

The contents of this page are also available for download (LowEffortSourdoughBread.pdf) as a printable PDF. Note: you can click on any image to enlarge it.

You may be wondering why a page about sourdough bread is co-located on a website devoted to apples. This FAQ Entry provides an explanation if you are interested.

A Summary of the Procedure

The summary below assumes you wish to bake a loaf of bread in the morning for consumption that day. If you wish to bake in the evening you are going to have to shift the timings back appropriately. The steps below are a summary - you can find an annotated and expanded version of each step further on in this document.

  1. Around 12:00 noon the day before, take the jar of sourdough starter out of the fridge and place it on the kitchen counter. At this point you are not doing anything – you are just letting it warm up.
  2. At around 6:00 pm that evening, pour the entire jar of sourdough starter into a mixing bowl and add some strong white flour and warm water till you double or triple the volume. Stir the mixture into a slurry. You are not making dough at this point – all you want to do now is give the natural yeasts in the starter some extra food and a chance to reproduce.
  3. At about bedtime (10:00 to 11:00 pm) you will have noticed many bubbles in the mixture. Take some of the slurry and use a spoon to put it back in the sourdough starter jar. This will be your sourdough starter the next time you bake bread so be sure to replace as much as you started with earlier on.
  4. The remainder of the starter is now available to make bread. Get some warm water, two eggs and some strong brown flour and some strong white flour. Break the eggs into the mixing bowl and add the brown and white flour and water to make up a paste. Keep adding water and flour until you have enough volume. The mixture will expand by a factor of 2 or 3 when it rises so you need a lot less than you think.
  5. At this point the sourdough mixture should have no lumps and should have the consistency of a cake mixture. It should not slop around if you move the bowl but also it should be nowhere near thick enough to knead.
  6. Pour the sourdough mixture into a soft silicone baking mould. You can purchase these online. Since the sourdough mixture will expand by a factor of 2 or 3 you want the level of the mixture to be quite a bit below the top of the mould or it will spill over and make a mess when it rises.
  7. Set the mixture in the mould somewhere warm and place a plastic bag loosely over the top of it to stop it from drying out.
  8. The process in steps 3 through 7 should take less than 10 minutes. Remember you are not kneading any dough. Just mixing the starter, flour, eggs (which are optional) and water into a paste.
  9. Leave the mixture in the mould overnight to rise. In the morning set your oven to 235°C and pre-heat for 15 minutes or until it warms up. Put a small bowl of water in at this time as well. This will get the humidity up inside the oven.
  10. After the oven has heated up, place the silicone mould with the newly risen sourdough mixture straight into the heated oven. Bake it for 35 minutes. Note: Do NOT take the sourdough mixture out of the mould. Do NOT knead the dough in any way – treat it like you would a cake. The moulds (assuming you got the right kind) are designed to be baked in and this simplifies the process considerably.
  11. After the bread has baked, take the mould with the bread out of the oven and tip it out onto a tray to cool down. You should find that the bread has risen nicely and absolutely did not stick to the mould.
  12. Let the bread cool down a bit (it will be very hot) and then it will be ready to eat. You may need to adjust the baking times and temperatures to suit your oven and mould sizes.
  13. Put the jar of starter you saved in step 3 back in the fridge for next time.

Annotated Instructions for Low Effort Sourdough Bread

The following is a longer and annotated version of the above instructions (including pictures).

Sourdough Starter and Where to Get It

I strongly doubt that the sourdough starter I use for my Low Effort sourdough bread is anything particularly special. I believe that pretty much any sourdough starter in the specified Low Effort procedure would probably work.

It is possible to make your own sourdough starter. Simply mix some strong white flour with warm water and leave it exposed to the air. Within about 10 days natural yeasts will begin to colonise it and you will see it start to foam and rise. Some people like to place small scraps of fruit peel or other similar materials in the starter to encourage local yeasts to colonise it. I tried this and although it did make sourdough it was not as good as sourdough starter specifically obtained as “sourdough starter”. This is reasonable as some starters will be better than others and over time the poor ones would have been discarded in favour of the better ones.

In my case, the starter used is a hybrid – I tried making my own, obtained some online (just purchased it) and was given some. After various trial and error attempts, I just mixed them all together and now use that. The starter is stored open to the air so presumably it is continually acquiring new yeasts from environment as well. This may well change the starter over time. I do not care much about this since, in my experience, the starter only seems to get better.

Caring for the Sourdough Starter

Sourdough starter is a living thing – it needs to be fed. You cannot just leave it for months at a time and expect it to be viable. Having said that one sees instructions on the Internet stating that starters need to be fed once per day (some even say twice a day). I have not found this to be necessary - once per week is sufficient. Note that the act of making bread via the Low Effort procedure is equivalent to feeding the starter. In the event that you do not make bread once a week just take the jar of starter out of the fridge, scoop out the top third of the starter and discard it, add more strong white flour and warm water and stir. I keep my starter in the fridge when not in use – but after feeding (or baking bread) I leave it out for 3-4 hours so the yeasts can eat and breed.

Step 1: Warm Up the Starter

Starter Pot
…take the jar of sourdough starter out of the fridge and place it on the kitchen counter… All you are doing here is getting the yeast active again. I store the starter in the fridge in a small Kilner jar for convenience and it will mostly be dormant in the cold. You could make bread with cold starter but you would have to allow more time for it to get to work and rise. Note that the starter jar in the image to the left is in a bowl (for spills) and has a cloth over it to keep out flies. The lid of the jar is slightly open to expose the contents to the air. I like to let new yeasts colonize the starter if they wish and have noticed a gradual improvement in the quality (rise and taste) over time.

Step 2: Increase the Amount of Sourdough Starter

step2-PlaceStarterInBowl
… pour the entire jar of sourdough starter into a mixing bowl and add… At this point you need to make more starter – the bread rises a lot faster if there is a larger initial quantity of starter and you will also need to replace the starter you use so you have some for next time. Just scoop out the starter into a mixing bowl. You may see a thin layer of evil looking grey liquid on top of the starter. This is called the “liquor” and is just alcohol – the waste product of the yeasts. You can discard this if you wish but your resulting bread will be much sourer (and I think better tasting) if you keep it. So, even though it does not look all that attractive, I just pour the liquor into the bowl along with the rest of the starter and mix it all in.
step2-AddFlourAndWater
Add strong white flour and warm water to increase the volume in the bowl by about 2 or 3 times. In later steps you will be adding eggs (optionally) or brown flour (optionally) but do not add them at this point. Part of the contents of this bowl will go back into the sourdough starter pot and you really only want strong white flour and water in that. Note that you do not need to measure in any of these steps just keep adding strong white flour and warm water and mixing it up until the volume is about 2-3 times what you started with. The mixture should be a reasonably lump free slurry when you are done. It should definitely NOT be a stiff kneadable dough. The water you add should be warm enough to be able to comfortably put your hand in it. Do not using boiling water – the yeasts will just die. You can use cold water but it just makes things slower.

Now let the mixture sit for about 4 hours in order to let the natural yeasts in the starter feed and reproduce. Be sure to cover it with a tea towel or similar to keep out bugs.

Step 3: Replace the Sourdough Starter Back Into the Jar

Step3-RefillTheStarterJar
… take some of the slurry and use a spoon to put it back in the sourdough starter jar… After leaving the starter mixture in the bowl for 3-4 hours you can begin to use it. However, you don’t want the first sourdough loaf you make to be your last so you will need to save some of the mixture back into your original starter jar so that you can use it again in the next batch. Just take a large spoon and scoop out enough of the mixture to fill it nearly to the top and then put the jar aside. Leave the top ajar and cover it to keep out the flies.

Step 4: Make the Sourdough Mixture for the Bread

Step4-MakeTheBreadDough
…the remainder of the starter is now available to make bread… Here you are making the dough that will be baked as bread. The process is simple – just add flour and warm water to the remnants of the starter until you get enough mixture. I also like to add two eggs at this point – but that’s mostly because I have my own hens and I have lots of eggs. I don’t think it makes all that much difference to the resulting loaf so you can consider the eggs to be optional. I also add strong brown flour and sometimes seeded flours at this point – they make the bread taste nice and nutty. The type of flour you use here is your choice – but definitely don’t add the eggs and odd flours before putting the starter back into the Kilner jar. Only strong white flour should be used for the starter. As before, you do not need to measure the flour and water. Just add it in and stir until you get the volume about 1/2 of the size of loaf you need. The mixture will expand by a factor of 2 or 3 when it rises so you need a lot less than you think. Make the bread a few times and experience will soon tell you how much dough you need.

Step 5: Make sure the Consistency is Correct

Step5-MakeTheConsistencyCorrect
… the sourdough mixture should have no lumps and should have the consistency of cake mixture… Before you use the sourdough mixture make sure the consistency is correct. No doubt you have seen people kneading bread with their hands – this is NOT the way it is done in this Low Effort procedure. What you want is something similar to a cake mixture. Add flour or warm water until the sourdough is not runny and sloppy if the bowl is moved but also is not so thick it could be kneaded. It should be easily stir-able with a spatula and should have no major lumps.

Step 6: Pour the Sourdough Mixture into the Mould

Step6-PourTheDoughIntoTheMould
… pour the sourdough mixture into a soft silicone baking mould… Here’s the trick. If you have looked at videos on the Internet you have doubtless seen many examples of people kneading dough, letting it rise in a proving basket and kneading it again etc. I have had really bad luck doing this. It takes a long time, the bread invariably sticks to the containers in a very annoying way and I eventually give up in frustration. With this Low Effort procedure you do not need to do any of that. All you need is a Silicone Non-Stick Baking Mould – many examples of which are readily available online.
Step6-PourTheDoughIntoTheMould
Silicone moulds look like they are soft and floppy rubber – but they are oven safe. They are the only baking tray I have found that bread dough absolutely will not stick to. You do not need to put oil or anything on them – just use them as they are. I like the brown bread moulds (shown in the image at left) which produce a boat shaped banneton style loaf. There are more traditional rectangular moulds as well. These work with no problems but they are a bit too small for me and the rising dough often foams over the top and then I have an annoying mess to clean up.

Pour the sourdough mixture into the silicone baking mould. Since the sourdough mixture will expand by a factor of 2 or 3 you want the level of the mixture to be quite a bit below the top of the mould or it will spill over and make a mess when it rises.

In the image on the left you can see the volume of dough is considerably smaller than the size of the mould. Also note the consistency of the mixture. It is not runny and it is not so stiff you could knead it.

Step 7: Let the Mixture Rise

Step7-PlaceBagOverMould
…set the mixture in the mould somewhere warm and place a plastic bag loosely over the top… At this point you have done all of the hard work. Just place a plastic bag over the top and place it somewhere warmish to rise for 8-10 hours or so. Note that the bag is not tight to the top. I use a fairly stiff plastic bag that came with some takeaway food for this purpose.

I typically arrange the scheduling of the baking process so that the 8-10 hour rise time happens overnight and then I can bake the bread first thing in the morning.

Step 9: Pre-heat the oven

Step9-SmallBowlOfWater
…after the dough has risen, set your oven to 235°C and pre-heat for 15 minutes or until it warms up… You need a warm oven to bake the bread. You definitely do not want to place the newly risen dough in a cold oven. Try to resist the temptation to take the bag off and see how well your mixture rose. Unlike breads with stiff dough, and like just about every cake, you can collapse the bubbles out of the newly risen mixture by messing around with it too much. Place a small bowl of water in the back of the oven. This will heat up and raise the humidity in the oven and the crust will not be too hard. You can leave the bowl out if you like really hard crusts on your bread.

Step 10: Bake the Bread

Step10-PlaceMouldInOven
…place the silicone mould with the newly risen sourdough mixture straight into the heated oven… The really great thing about the silicone baking moulds is that they go straight in the oven. Honestly they do – they look like they will melt down into a plastic rubbery goo, but no, they are specifically designed for this. This means that once the mixture is in the mould it need not be transferred out and you can make the mixture a lot looser than you normally would be able to do. Leave the dough in the mould - do NOT knead the dough in any way – treat it like you would a cake.

The bread is baked for 35 minutes at 235°C. The small bowl of water is still in the oven as can be seen in the image. You may need a slightly longer time for larger loaves and a shorter time for smaller ones. Experience will show you how to get this right for your oven.

Step 11: Take the Bread Out of the Oven

Step11-TakeTheBreadOutOfTheOven
… take the mould with the bread out of the oven and tip it out onto a tray… The bread will bake in the oven and turn into a nice sourdough loaf in the mould. Once it is done just take it out of the oven and tip it out of the mould onto a tray. The bread will come out easily and there will be no sticking or other mess. If you tip it out upside down you can gently tap on the bottom of the loaf. If you get a hollow knocking sound it is done, if you get a squishy thud like sound you can just put the mould back around it and pop it back into the oven for another 5 minutes or so. Be careful while doing this – both the mould and bread will be very hot.

Let the bread cool down a bit and then it will be ready to eat.

Step 12: Put the Starter Back in the Fridge

Starter Pot
… put the jar of starter you saved in step 3 back in the fridge for next time… Back in Step 3 you replaced the starter in the jar with some of the new mixture. The rest of the mixture went on to form the basis of the bread. I usually leave the starter out (suitably covered) alongside the bread in the mould while it rises. This gives the yeast in the starter a bit of time to eat and reproduce in the warmth. When I put the bread in the oven to bake I put the starter back in the fridge for next time.

Conclusion

TheBakedBread
The thing that makes the Low Effort Sourdough process work so well is the usage of silicone bread moulds. These moulds remove the time consuming requirement to knead the dough and turn the process of making a sourdough loaf into something much more like making a cake.

Why does it work? The kneading process breaks down the cellulose chains in the flour and makes more sugars available for the yeast to feast on. My theory is that probably the extra water in the Low Effort dough and the unusually long rise time compensate for the lack of kneading and achieve much the same effect.

I have found that the bubbles in the Low Effort sourdough bread are not as large as in “proper” sourdough bread but, as you can see, there are plenty of smaller bubbles. The bread is also not as light and “fluffy” as is typical – but it is not a dense block either. It tastes the same though and the resulting loaf resembles a traditional peasant bread. The other characteristic I have noted is its keeping ability – the bread is truly excellent on the day it is made (freshly made bread always is) but on day 5 it is still pretty much just as good as it was on day 2.

Once you get the hang of it, the entire process detailed here probably requires no more than 10 minutes worth of effort on the part of the baker. Most of the time is spent waiting for the yeasts to work their magic.

Good luck with your bread making.